Of Halo 3, Bioshock, Call of Duty 4, Mass Effect, and The Orange Box...

[Nick]

...which 1 should be True Game of the Year!? State which game and why it is the True "Game of the Year."

If someone can miraclous convince me that either Bioshock or The Orange Box should have won then I will award you with the 10 points, otherwise let the games begin!!

 

[Metallica20]

Bioshock no contest
that game got 10 out of 10
and in spikes videogame award, bioshock got game of the year

 

[einstein]

bioshock. the single player is simply so amazing and so deep that you cant put it down. the graphics are awsome. the story is like a hollywood suspense script. there is so much action it doesn't need a multiplayer component.

 

[TJ2006]

Halo 3 is the best so far but Bio shock is going strong! Great graphics and the story is more detailed - all the games you have listed are 100% great but these 2 are the top! Have u looked at Kane and Lynch?

 

[Masta Chief]

Call of Duty 4, why should you give 10 pts for Orange Box/Bioshock? I am not saying they are bad games, it is just that it is not fair. Cod 4 because it is better !!!!

 

[Kevin T]

CALL OF DUTY 4!!!!!!!!
it has an awesome single player and multiplayer